SAI for Organization Diagnosis: Five methods for consultants and researchers to use emotional, perceptual, and cognitive aspects of their selves as diagnostic tools.
1.EMOTIONAL REACTIONS
2.INITIAL PERCEPTIONS
3.UNDERSTAND BIAS
4.POSTPONING JUDGEMENT
5.FANTASIES AND IMAGES
EMOTIONAL REACTIONS, feelings are data, they can be a metaphor for an organization, source for hypothesis testing, feelings of surprise can indicate an incomplete diagnosis; specific feelings may indicate specific conditions
INITIAL PERCEPTIONS, because habitual processes can interfere with perceptions, first impressions of the organization can be the clearest; consultants can ask themselves about how they feel initially about the architecture ot the leadership.
UNDERSTAND BIAS, to view others in unbiased way consultant needs to know their own bias up front, otherwise our feelings may have more to do with our past “Since the primary instrument in OD work is the consultant practitioner, it is important that one know this instruiment as well as possible” Burke, 1982, p. 358
POSTPONING JUDGEMENT, suspending critical judgement to avoid speculation and premature evaluations; listening to client in an open-ended way that postpones conclusions w/o toher data.
FANTASIES AND IMAGES, suggest a better way to organize the data, free association
BENEFITS of Using Self for Diagnosis
Triangulation of the data
Initial hypothesis
Creative hypotheses
Integrative hypotheses
Inexpensive and accessible data
Reducing stress
PROBLEMS of Using Self for Diagnosis
Arrogance of the consultant to only use the self
No statistical research on the use of self in organization diagnosis – therefore not sure if it is reliable
Sharing feelings can be inappropriate at times
Sharing a hypothesis needs to be from a tentative point of view
From a paper presented at the 37th Annual Western Academy of Management Conference, March 28-30, 1996, Banff, Alberta, Canada. Nominee for Best Paper Award. An early version of this paper was given by Don McCormick at the 1987 Organization Development Conference in Seattle. Author: Donald W. McCormick, Ph.D.